Grade a coin
We buy coins

Sell to us

A written offer for the good ones, and honest advice on the rest.

We buy pennies

Sell your coins without getting fleeced.

Most jar collections we review are worth face value plus a little metal — and we’ll tell you that for free. But key dates, error coins, silver, and gold get a real cash offer based on the same price data in our database. What we pay for:

What we buy
  • Key dates & errors — 1909-S VDB, 1914-D, doubled dies, 1943 bronze suspects (we pay for winners; authentication handled through PCGS/NGC)
  • Wheat cent lots — rolls, cans, and albums, 1909–1958
  • Bulk pre-1982 copper cents — priced per pound off the copper calculator
  • Silver & gold coins — 90% silver, Morgans, gold eagles: priced off live spot
  • Whole estates — see the Estate Sort service
Written offers, no pressure Coins insured in transit Anything we don’t buy, returned free

No obligation. We reply within 2 business days — or call/text (218) 779-4332. Never clean your coins before selling — cleaning destroys value.

Thanks — your message is ready in your email app. Hit send and we’ll reply within 2 business days.
Services

Know what you have. Then decide.

From a printable hunting checklist to a full estate sort — pick the level of help you need.

Start here

Penny Hunter’s Checklist

$19 one-time · instant PDF
What’s included
  • Every valuable date, mint mark & error variety on printable sheets
  • ID guides: doubled dies, Close AM vs Wide AM, small vs large dates
  • Magnet-and-scale workflow — sort a jar in an evening
  • Current value ranges + “get it graded?” thresholds
Buy the Checklist

Photo Appraisal

$29 up to 3 coins · 48-hour turnaround
What’s included
  • Email photos of your pennies — front and back
  • Written value estimate with comparable sales
  • Honest “worth grading?” verdict (PCGS/NGC routing)
  • Fair cash offer included if we want to buy them
Request Appraisal

Estate Penny Sort

$99 + 10% of sale proceeds
What’s included
  • Inherited a bucket, can, or safe full of pennies? Mail it in.
  • We sort, identify, and value every coin
  • Keys sent to auction; bulk copper sold at market
  • Itemized ledger of what sold and for how much
Start with the Sell Form

Bundle: Checklist + Photo Appraisal for $39 (save $9) — buy the checklist first, sort your jar, then send us the survivors.